Mr Howard, your closed mindedness is astounding.
I’m a spiritual atheist which means I care about the soul, rejoice in the diversity of the natural and human worlds, but don’t take comfort in projecting a father or mother figure or supreme consciousness onto all things. Even if I were in my last moments I would find no peace in knowing God was waiting for me because in my world this would mean ‘a psychological projection of mine – the teller- will await your soul after death’. This means little to me except that the person doing the telling felt afraid of death being the end of my animal life in and through my body and required a more comfortable way of rationalising my ending.
And why put their psychological struggle onto me, especially on my way out. I’d much prefer to hear an affirmation that I had given more than I took, that my time in this body had been useful, that my spirit touched and enriched the lives of others and will live on in the nostalgic inner worlds of those who loved and valued me after I’m gone. To me, this is the only heaven I’m fairly certain might have a space for me and I’m comfortable with that and need no grandiose beliefs that inflate my worth to any God.
We are facing many many challenges; global poverty, AIDS, wars, the horrendous disadvantages in many remote Indigenous communities, lack of services for those with disabilities, the destruction of rainforests, the progressive extinction of endangered species, the shocking prospects of global warming for all of our countries…. So what is our archaic right wing prime minister planning this week to spend 90 million dollars on? He wants to install chaplains in all our government schools with the faith to be nominated by the social majority associated with those schools and the government maintaining a right to withhold funding where it disliked the choices these school communities make.
Mr Howard had the audacity to claim that all people gain solace from consulting chaplains, including those without religion. Was he refering to spiritual atheists? He assumed we’d all like to be reassured God loves us when facing extreme crises.
I remember when we had religion taught in our primary school in the 1970s. I was about 11 and tried to believe in Jesus and hoped this ghost of a dead Jewish son of a royal family almost 2 thousand years ago might help stop the sickness of child abuse, alcoholism and the torture and killing of animals in our house. But, alas, this ghost did nothing. Perhaps I needed some water splashed on my head by someone who’d climbed the heirachy in a place that passed money bowls and adorned the room with golden ornamentation. So when I was in my 20s, I drank out of a big cement bird bath thingy in a Paris church. It had a dead moth floating in it but maybe he’d gone to be with God, I don’t know. But nothing changed. It was just water.
I’m sure there’s some very nice chaplains but if they care about the world, this planet and Australia in some lasting way, perhaps they’d like to waive the $20,000 schools would win for appointing them and recommend that these funds go towards something more spiritual and lasting than spreading religion among impressionable minds before they fully understand choice. After all, schools already have highly trained, impartial counselors. They could decide to leave it to the professionals.
… Donna Williams
I had thought this sort of thing was only going on in the U.S. – I’m Christian, but I also value religious diversity and think it is just wrong to force religion on people in this sort of way . . . what I always wonder is sort of what you are saying – how is it a choice if it is forced? To me a truly religious person (regardless of the actual religion they choose) is someone who has read about a lot of religions and said ‘Oh – this one really works for me . . .’ not someone who is so afraid they just blindly follow some religion that was forced on them . . .
But really it is all about doing good things and being nice to people (human people, animal people, object people, etc( – however you frame that
Unbelievable, and why the bias to one faith? What about Atheists and Humanists? In the UK, my government seems to be obsessed with faith schools, pigeon holeing pupils of certain religions with others of the same religion. This goes against maintaining diversity, which was what the comprehensive education system set out to do in England and Wales.
Counselling or chaplaining should be a secular thing rather than biased to one religion. The late founder of the UK’s National Health Service, Aneurin Bevan quoted in his book ‘In Place of Fear’: “What is worse than monopoly of ownership is monopoly of opinion”. Mr Howard has obviously not took heed of this quote.
Is Mr Howard remotely related to George W Bush?
He would love this idea. Thankfully with our recent election, we have democrats back in control, and can look forward to more social programs, and stricter environmental laws.
I cannot wait until 2007!
As always, you say it perfectly. I think you are a genius at communication!! (someone told me that once and i understand what she meant and was flattered, i guess…and you, i think are TRULY an expressive genius! I appreciate your explanation of being a Spiritual Athiest…I define the same way. I just wanted to thank you for explaining it so well. (The expressive genius…well that’s in reference to everything i’ve read by you!)
Hi Courtney,
I think that to know one is understood is truly a compliment enough.
To be read by those who don’t understand is also an honour if not a difficult one sometimes.
Spending my first 9-11 years unable to make much verbal ‘sense’ to other people and living in a discardable pile of those labeled psychotic or disturbed (labels commonly ascribed to people with autism in the 60s and 70s who had ‘dysfunctional language), means that when one gets functional language, seems it ought to at least be used usefully.
I hope, at least, it has some use.
🙂 Donna Williams *)
http://www.donnawilliams.net
oh it does. to me, it does. thank you.
I’ve spent my time being labelled bipolar or other but amin my elelment when I am one-on-one with an autistic student and we connect and do eveything everyone says can’t be done but besause we just know each other it’s easy.